Daniel Kilby, a contestant on Canadian Survivor, experienced a significant loss earlier this year when he misplaced numerous personal items, including a painting featuring a “cheetah dressed as a general,” his PlayStation 5, and various household appliances. This unfortunate event was a result of missed payments on a storage unit while he participated in the reality show, leading to his belongings being auctioned off.
“It was frustrating… I would think, ‘I want to make some sparkling water. Just kidding, you can’t,'” expressed the 30-year-old game designer, now residing in Halifax.
Kilby, who had been renting in London, Ontario, decided against paying rent while filming the 51st season of the popular reality series. To avoid ongoing rental costs, he opted to store most of his possessions in a storage locker for approximately $100 monthly and moved in with his girlfriend in Florida.
This arrangement allowed him to start his Survivor preparation, which included swimming lessons and fire-making practice.
However, during his flight to Florida in February, he lost his wallet, necessitating the acquisition of a new debit card and updates to his payment methods. Unfortunately, he overlooked one critical payment.
In mid-April, shortly before he departed for filming in Fiji, he discovered that he hadn’t updated his payment details with StorageMart in London. Despite attempting to communicate with the facility, he was unable to rectify the situation and chose to postpone it until after filming.

Kilby stands beside his treasured painting of a ‘cheetah dressed as a general.’ (Submitted by Daniel Kilby)
At that moment, his focus was on pursuing his dream and vying for the million-dollar prize on Survivor.
“I honestly, like, didn’t think they would actually auction off my belongings. I figured it was just a silly mistake I would sort out upon my return,” Kilby noted.
Returning Home
Kilby secured 11th place this season and was eliminated in the eighth episode, which aired on November 11, resulting in no million-dollar prize. Instead, he came back in June to face a significantly different financial situation.
The first email he encountered upon his return to Canada informed him that his storage unit—and all of its contents—was set to be auctioned.
While he was away, StorageMart had attempted to reach him to update his payment details and notify him of at least three missed payments. However, due to his isolation on an island with no means of communication, they were unable to get in touch.
“My phone was inundated. I had like a hundred emails from them saying, ‘Hey, you haven’t paid,'” Kilby recalled.
-
‘What just happened?’ Jeff Probst spoils Survivor 50 finale result live on air
-
Survivor changed reality TV. Now it’s celebrating its 50th season
Kilby contacted the storage facility in hopes of reclaiming his belongings. He was informed that he would need to pay $2,000 and retrieve his items immediately to recover them. This amount was substantial, and he would also have to rent a vehicle to transport everything.
“Plus, I thought, a lot of my stuff wasn’t even that great,” Kilby remarked, estimating the total value of his belongings at around $2,000.
CBC reached out to StorageMart for clarification on their late payment policies and when a unit is subject to auction but did not receive a response prior to publication.
According to StorageMart’s website, there is no grace period for late payments, and late fees will apply as specified in the customer’s lease. They also offer an online payment platform for clients and a 24/7 helpline.

Kilby secured 11th place in the most recent season of Survivor, which is ongoing. (Robert Voets/CBS)
With his belongings now up for auction, he devised another plan: bid on his own items, hoping that interest from others would be low.
With a bid of around $400, Kilby felt optimistic about the possibility of reclaiming his possessions. However, at the last moment, a bidder known as “Prince C” placed a bid that won the auction for $441.
“It’s harsh; it’s disappointing,” Kilby lamented. “I thought we were on track to win it, so I felt a bit foolish. But I also felt somewhat relieved because it meant I wouldn’t have to go pick it up.”
‘It’s a Humorous Tale’
Kilby described the items in his locker as ranging from IKEA furniture to a collection of Pokémon cards.
After the auction, he searched Facebook Marketplace in London, hoping to spot some of his items. He even reached out on Reddit, looking for the buyer’s information. There are certain personal items he wishes to reclaim.
“I had some sentimental things. For instance, there was that quirky painting of a cheetah dressed as a general, which I thought was really neat,” Kilby shared. “My mom knitted a bear that was among the items. That’s a real loss.”
Additionally, he has had to replace essential appliances like a SodaStream and a blender.
As for the rest of the belongings? He feels indifferent about their absence. Since filming, Kilby and his girlfriend relocated to Halifax, and he believes many items from that locker wouldn’t have made the journey anyway.
“It’s a humorous tale, and I tend to live my life in a way that creates entertaining stories,” Kilby reflected.
“It’s amusing how my passion for Survivor led to me losing all my things.”
