HomeFinanceEtsy Sellers Withdraw Products Amid Controversial AI Policy Backlash

Etsy Sellers Withdraw Products Amid Controversial AI Policy Backlash

Several Etsy sellers throughout Canada are withdrawing their products from the platform due to backlash against the company’s decision to implement artificial intelligence model training as part of a policy update.

Tsuki Matsuba, based in Vancouver, B.C., is taking her custom stationery items off Etsy in anticipation of a new AI policy set to be introduced next month.

“It felt like a kick in the teeth,” Matsuba expressed.

An excerpt from an update to the company’s terms and conditions, effective December 16, states that Etsy, along with its third-party partners and vendors, may utilize sellers’ content to “develop, train, test, and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies.”

KPMG, one of the world’s leading accounting and consulting firms, reported in 2025 that 88 percent of tech executives surveyed believe that companies adopting AI will gain a competitive advantage over those that do not.

The report also indicated that 68 percent of respondents anticipate a moderate to very high return on investment from AI-related investments—10 percent or more.

Backlash in Canada

After spending seven years in the animation field, Matsuba noted that AI significantly contributed to her job loss in that sector.

She worries that Etsy shop owners are “being forced” to make a choice between earning holiday revenue and staying on the platform under conditions that permit their content to be utilized for AI training.

A growing number of Etsy shop owners in Canada are taking down their products and original creations due to worries that their work could be used for AI training.

Artist Tina Nawrocki, located in Ottawa, announced on X that she is “closing down” her Etsy shop in response to the company’s “new predatory AI practices.”

Halifax-based artist, The Calendork, revealed it has withdrawn all its artwork from its Etsy shop while keeping it open due to the “new insane AI policies.”

‘Should have communicated better’

James Ossman, Etsy’s head of customer operations, stated that honoring the work of its sellers is “central” to the operation of Etsy.

He mentioned that sellers’ “creative work belongs to them,” and Etsy does not utilize that work for training “AI models designed to replicate their original work or supplant their creativity.”

WATCH | Indigenous artists affected by Etsy’s fur ban:

Etsy to ban the sale of fur, with some Indigenous artists affected most

April 15|

Duration

2:27

The company intends to keep engaging with sellers regarding the policy change to “clarify what we mean and our intent in the Terms,” Ossman noted.

He added that the company “should have communicated more effectively” about the upcoming changes in Etsy’s policies to its sellers.

However, for Matsuba, these discussions will not alter her choice to cease selling her products on the platform.

“My business is entirely AI-free,” she stated, “I don’t want to be involved in the further development of AI.”

Must Read
Related News